Northern League
Dundee Hibs1–0Montrose
Lineups
Dundee Hibs
Montrose
Dundee Hibs · Starting XI
Montrose · Starting XI
- Paterson
- Chapman
- Geordie Clark
- McKenzie
- Black
- Adamson
- Murray
- McDonald
- Brown
- Ford
- Burness
Dundee Hibs · Substitutes
- Not recorded
Montrose · Substitutes
- Not recorded
Dundee Hibs · Substitutions
- Not recorded
Montrose · Substitutions
- Not recorded
Dundee Hibs · Manager
Montrose · Manager
- Not recorded
Match report
Dundee Hibs were good value for their narrow win over Montrose, but if they mean to beat Brechin next Sarurday and make progress in the Qualifying Cup ties they must show improved form. There was a want of balance in the front line, and good chances of scoring were missed. The defence was generally good, although the half-back line could have done with a little stiffening up. The Hibs, however, were hardly at full strength. Gallacher was out of the team owing to illness, and, while Strachan played well at right back, he is more serviceable in the mid line,…Read moreRead less
Dundee Hibs were good value for their narrow win over Montrose, but if they mean to beat Brechin next Sarurday and make progress in the Qualifying Cup ties they must show improved form. There was a want of balance in the front line, and good chances of scoring were missed. The defence was generally good, although the half-back line could have done with a little stiffening up. The Hibs, however, were hardly at full strength. Gallacher was out of the team owing to illness, and, while Strachan played well at right back, he is more serviceable in the mid line, being a fine, strong, forcing player.
Brady did not have much to do in goal. He was well guarded by the backs. Hannan played a fine game, and his powerful kicking was, as usual, a feature. The halves did good work in brewing up, but their feeding of the forwards was deficient. Snee was an active worker, and so was Boland, but Ramsay was below his best. Among the forwards, Docherty showed some smart footwork, and so did Dailly, but they were inclined to be selfish at time, forgetting their partners. E. F. Gibb, the amateur outside right, made a creditable show. He has any amount of dash and speed, and can shoot well. Henry Brown was the best of the five. Burns did fairly well in the centre position.
From The Courier (Dundee), Monday, August 30th, 1909.
Brady did not have much to do in goal. He was well guarded by the backs. Hannan played a fine game, and his powerful kicking was, as usual, a feature. The halves did good work in brewing up, but their feeding of the forwards was deficient. Snee was an active worker, and so was Boland, but Ramsay was below his best. Among the forwards, Docherty showed some smart footwork, and so did Dailly, but they were inclined to be selfish at time, forgetting their partners. E. F. Gibb, the amateur outside right, made a creditable show. He has any amount of dash and speed, and can shoot well. Henry Brown was the best of the five. Burns did fairly well in the centre position.
From The Courier (Dundee), Monday, August 30th, 1909.